Myths About Student Loans
The Truth Behind Common Myths About Student Loans
Navigating the world of student loans can be a complicated and sometimes overwhelming task.
With a plethora of information available, it is easy for misconceptions to take root and
spread. These myths can lead to misguided decisions, potentially affecting a student’s
financial future. This article addresses ten common myths about student loans, providing
clarity and insights to help borrowers make informed decisions. By debunking these myths,
we aim to empower students and their families with the knowledge needed to navigate the
complexities of student loans effectively.
Myth #1: Cutting the interest rate in half cuts the monthly loan payment in half.
Many borrowers believe that reducing their loan’s interest rate by half will similarly
halve their monthly payments. However, this is not necessarily true. While a lower
interest rate can reduce the total amount paid over the life of the loan, it does not
directly cut the payment in half. The structure of loan amortization, which includes both
principal and interest payments, means that reducing the interest rate affects only the
portion of the payment attributed to interest.
The actual impact on monthly payments depends on various factors: the original loan amount,
the remaining term of the loan, and the difference between the original and new interest
rates. Borrowers should use a loan calculator to understand the precise impact on their
monthly payments.
Myth #2: Federal loan consolidation lowers your interest rate.
Consolidating federal student loans is a common strategy for simplifying loan
payments. However, a consolidation loan does not reduce your interest rate. Instead,
it replaces multiple loans with a single loan, with the new interest rate being the
weighted average of the interest rates of the loans being consolidated, rounded up to
the nearest one-eighth of one percent.
While consolidation can simplify monthly payments and provide access to alternative
repayment plans, including income-driven repayment options, it will not lead to savings
through a lower interest rate. Borrowers should carefully weigh the pros and cons of
consolidation to determine if it aligns with their financial goals.
Myth #3: Refinancing student loans always saves you money.
Refinancing student loans can lead to savings, but this is not guaranteed across the board.
The savings potential depends on several factors, including your credit score, current
interest rates, and the terms offered by the refinancing lender. Borrowers with excellent
credit benchmarks may qualify for significantly lower rates, leading to substantial savings.
However, refinancing is not always beneficial. It involves converting federal loans into
private loans, which means losing access to federal protections such as income-driven
repayment plans and forgiveness programs. Before refinancing, students should consider
their ability to forgo these federal benefits, especially if they anticipate needing
them in the future.
Myth #4: Most borrowers can get a private student loan without a creditworthy cosigner.
Securing a private student loan without a cosigner is a common misconception. Most
private lenders require a cosigner to mitigate risks. A cosigner shares the responsibility
for loan repayment should the primary borrower default, offering the lender additional
security.
Borrowers with established credit histories and strong financial standing may secure a
loan without a cosigner. However, young students often lack sufficient credit history,
thus necessitating a cosigner. It’s crucial to carefully consider the implications of
cosigning on both the borrower and the cosigner’s financial situations.
Myth #5: You will have to pay a fee if you pay off your student loans early.
Contrary to some beliefs, paying off student loans ahead of schedule usually incurs
no fees. Both federal and most private student loans allow borrowers to make extra
payments or repay in full without penalty. Early repayment can save significant amounts
in interest over time, reducing the total cost of the loan.
Borrowers should confirm their specific loan terms to ensure no prepayment penalties
are in place, though these are uncommon for student loans. Taking advantage of these
no-fee early payoff options is a sound financial strategy for those with the means
to do so.
Myth #6: Federal student loans stop accruing interest during a forbearance.
While forbearance allows borrowers temporary relief from making loan payments, it
does not halt the accrual of interest on federal student loans. Interest continues
to accumulate during periods of forbearance, which can increase the total balance
upon resumption of payments.
Borrowers should consider the long-term impact of opting for forbearance, as the
accrued interest can be capitalized, increasing the loan’s principal balance. Income-driven
repayment plans may provide a better alternative for those facing financial hardship,
as they adjust monthly payments based on income.
Myth #7: Shopping around for a lower interest rate will hurt your credit score.
A common concern among borrowers is that seeking better interest rates through multiple
inquiries will damage their credit score. However, credit scoring models often consider
inquiries for similar loans made within a short timeframe as a single inquiry.
This practice, known as rate shopping, allows borrowers to explore different lenders
without fearing substantial negative impacts on their credit score. Borrowers should
time their inquiries carefully and engage with multiple lenders to identify the most
favorable terms available.
Myth #8: You don’t have to repay your federal student loans if you drop out of college.
Regardless of whether a student completes their degree, federal student loans require
repayment. The obligation to repay begins following a grace period post-enrollment,
typically six months after leaving school, even if a degree was not obtained.
It’s essential for borrowers who leave college early to discuss the situation with
their loan servicer and explore their repayment options. Deferment or income-driven
plans may be available to assist with managing payments while in transition.
Myth #9: Eligibility for a federal student loan is based on your credit score.
Unlike private student loans, federal student loans do not require a credit check or
consider a borrower’s credit score for eligibility. Federal loans are designed to be
accessible to students, regardless of their credit history, making them more widely
available.
There are exceptions, such as PLUS loans, which do require a credit check. However,
the vast majority of federal loans, including Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans,
are not credit-based and thus available to most students who demonstrate financial need
via the FAFSA.
Myth #10: Refinancing your federal student loans into a private loan will save you money.
While refinancing federal loans into private loans can offer lower interest rates for
borrowers with strong credit profiles, it also comes with significant trade-offs. Moving
loans to a private lender means sacrificing federal benefits, including income-driven
repayment plans and loan forgiveness options.
Borrowers should conduct a rigorous analysis of these trade-offs before committing to
refinancing. For some, the immediate savings on interest may not outweigh the loss of
federal protections, especially if financial circumstances change over time.
Final Thoughts
| Myth | Truth |
|---|---|
| Cutting the interest rate in half cuts the monthly loan payment in half. | Interest rate reduction affects only the interest portion, not the entire payment. |
| Federal loan consolidation lowers your interest rate. | Consolidation calculates a weighted average, not a lower rate. |
| Refinancing student loans always saves you money. | Savings depend on credit, terms; refinancing forfeits federal benefits. |
| Most borrowers can get a private student loan without a creditworthy cosigner. | Most private loans require a cosigner for approval. |
| You will have to pay a fee if you pay off your student loans early. | No prepayment penalties for early payoff. |
| Federal student loans stop accruing interest during a forbearance. | Interest continues to accrue during forbearance. |
| Shopping around for a lower interest rate will hurt your credit score. | Rate shopping within short periods is considered a single inquiry. |
| You don’t have to repay your federal student loans if you drop out of college. | Federal loans require repayment whether you graduate or not. |
| Eligibility for a federal student loan is based on your credit score. | Federal loans mostly do not require credit checks. |
| Refinancing your federal student loans into a private loan will save you money. | Refinancing saves interest but forfeits federal loan benefits. |


